In Matthew 23:23-32, Jesus has a conversation with the Jewish religious leaders. In order to put that conversation in context, we need a bit of background.
Prior to this conversation, Jesus has entered Jerusalem in triumph – the Palm Sunday procession – being welcomed by the ordinary people as the Messiah. He then went straight to the Temple and threw out the traders and moneychangers from the Court of the Gentiles.
The following morning, on the way back into Jerusalem after a night spent outside the city, Jesus pauses to curse a fig-tree that has no figs on it.
Then when Jesus gets to the temple, the religious leaders start to question him about why he thinks he has the authority to do the things he is doing. It is a fair question. Jesus has not been trained in any of the rabbinic schools. No official body has recognised his knowledge, his sanctity, his skills, or his gifting. He is an unknown person from the provinces and unconnected to any religious hierarchy or structure. So where does Jesus get his authority?
Now, there are two possible sources for spiritual authority.
The priests, the teachers of the Law, the temple hierarchy all get their authority from human religious structures. In the same way that I was ordained a priest by a Bishop in the Church of England, so any spiritual authority that I have comes from that ordination. But Jesus has none of that.
The other source of authority is that of the prophets. These men and women receive a divine commission directly from God to declare a message that He gives them.
But Jesus does not claim either of those sources of authority. Instead, Jesus responds to their question with a question; “Where did John the Baptist get his authority?” Jesus offers to answer their question, if they will first answer his.
But it is a clever trap, and the religious leaders can’t bring themselves to give an answer.
John the Baptist didn’t get his authority from any human religious structure. So, the only other possibility is to recognise that he was a prophet sent from God. But if they say that, then they condemn themselves for not accepting his message. Everyone knew that John had condemned the religious authorities, calling them “a brood of vipers”, and he had criticised them for hypocrisy and spiritual pride.
But that denial of John’s prophetic authority from God will be a problem, because the common people did consider John the Baptist to be a prophet.
So, in the silent stalemate of two unanswered questions, Jesus tells a story. On the surface, it is a very simple story. It concerns two sons and a Father – a very common structure for Jesus’ parables. Both sons are asked by the Father to go and work in the family vineyard.
The first son answers impolitely and flat out refuses to go. The second calls his Father ‘Sir’ and promises to go straight away. But then both sons have a change of heart.
The rude, and seemingly disobedient son, reconsiders his refusal and then goes and works as requested. While the respectful and seemingly obedient son, reconsiders and then decides not to go.
Now, this is a very common experience. This is everyman’s story. We have all been here. You ask for people for help, some people say all the right things. “Of course I’ll help, you just have to ask, I would be delighted” And, in the moment everyone is happy. You think you have people who are going to help you and a nice human exchange has occurred. Everyone feels warm and fuzzy. But then the day comes and no help arrives. You feel let down, made a fool of, angry.
Other people say straight to your face. “Nah, I’m not going to help with that. Not my thing. I just don’t have the time.” In the moment you feel deflated, awkward. You wonder about the true depth of your relationship. But when the day comes, they unexpectedly turn up to help. “Just thought I’d pop in, I felt bad about saying no.” And you feel elated, happy, like there really are supportive people around you.
So, this is an experience we have all had, it is a very human story. Jesus then asks a simple and unthreatening question, “Which son do you think did his Father’s will?”
It is not a hard question. The answer is obvious, the son who actually obeyed. The son whose first response was unpromising, confrontational, negative. But who then came around and did the right thing.
As usual with Jesus, this simple story was actually anything but. In this parable and in the one that follows it, the Parable of the Wicked Tenants, Jesus is following John the Baptist in bringing a harsh critique of the Jewish religious leaders and exposing their spiritual failure and wickedness. It is a kind of declaration of war.
The parable’s meaning is stark. John the Baptist really had come from God. He had told the people what God had told him to say and called them to repent of their sins and prepare themselves for the coming of the Messiah.
The people who looked like unpromising candidates for spiritual renewal, the common people, – people whose lives often looked more like a ‘No’ to God than a ‘Yes’ – they had responded positively to John’s message. They repented. They came to be baptised by John as a sign that they were turning their lives around. So, although they initially looked like unpromising candidates, they actually ended up saying ‘Yes’ to God.
But the religious leaders, the pious and the spiritually observant, were the exact opposite. Their lives looked very much like a ‘Yes’ to God. They lived right, they prayed right, they fasted right, they went to the temple and to the synagogue. But although their lives looked like a ‘Yes’, they refused to receive John’s message. They refused to repent or be baptised, instead they opposed John as much as they could. Their lives might have looked like a ‘Yes’ but their response was ‘No’.
They were now doing the same thing with Jesus. Instead of agreeing with Jesus that the temple needed to be cleansed and function as a House of Prayer for all nations, they instead took issue with his actions.
The related story of the fig-tree that Jesus cursed because it didn’t bear any fruit, is an acted out condemnation of their failure. Their religion was all pious words and outward forms, but their lives didn’t bear the kind of fruit that God is looking for – Love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, gentleness, faithfulness, and self-control. Their words said ‘Yes’, but their lives said ‘No’. Because they did not produce good fruit, Jesus curses them.
Often in the Bible, the point is made that doing the will of God is more important than knowing God. Of course, it is better when you have both of these – when you do God’s will and have some understanding of who God is. But of the two it is always obedience in scripture that is seen as the most important. So, in Matthew’s gospel, the fundamental question is not simply whether you KNOW God but whether you DO the will of God.
Which reminds of a statement that I first heard at Bible college some 30 years ago. It stopped me in my tracks that day and it still does today. One of my fellow students stood up in chapel and said this, “The only scriptures that you really know are the ones that you obey.”
Think about that for a while. Are there any scriptures that you know, but struggle to put into practice? For example, “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength. Love your neighbour as yourself.”
Are you all square with that one? I confess that I struggle. If my fellow student was correct, “The only scriptures that you really know are the ones that you obey.” then there are lots of scriptures that I really don’t know at all.
But obeying God always has two components. This is brilliantly illustrated in the book ‘Moby Dick’ by Herman MELVILLE. The central character joins a whaling ship but before setting out to sea, the sailors go to church. The priest Father MAPPLE preaches a sermon. From the book of Jonah, of course! And it is a sermon about obedience and disobedience. In it he says this;
But all the things that God would have us do are hard for us to do- remember that- and hence, he oftener commands us than endeavours to persuade.
And if we obey God, we must disobey ourselves; and it is in this disobeying ourselves, wherein the hardness of obeying God consists.
Herman MELVILLE got that completely right. We have to ‘disobey’ ourselves in order to obey God, and that is often very hard.
We must say no to our own inclinations, our own desires, our own wants, our own priorities. If we cannot do that, then we will never obey God. Our bodies shout out their desires and demands, our culture screams at us, telling us what we should want and what we should do, and yet God calls us to disobey those strident calls.
The only thing that makes it possible for us to disobey ourselves are the spiritual disciplines. These spiritual practices help us hold our fleshly desires in check. They also present to us the shallowness, falseness, and ultimate emptiness of the things our culture values and prioritises.
Our culture says that we are in a competition and that the one who dies with the most toys wins. We see old men in their 80s still desperately trying to amass more wealth, more property, more stuff. It is the whole focus of their life. And yet it is ultimately meaningless. What do they take with them into eternity? Nothing. There is an old Scottish saying, “There’s nae pockets in a shroud”.
The spiritual disciplines present us with a different vision for our lives. They remind us that we are temporary beings, on a temporary formation course, preparing ourselves to be the kind of people who can rule and reign with Christ for eternity. That is the reality and meaning of our existence. That should be the focus of our lives. We win at life when we cooperate with the Holy Spirit in our own transformation into people who come to resemble Jesus, just a little bit more each day.
Jesus’ critique of the religious leaders was that they were ‘all talk and no trousers’. They talked a very good game. As Jesus said to his disciples, ‘The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat; therefore, do whatever they teach you and follow it, but do not do as they do, for they do not practice what they teach’.
That is a heavy challenge that I feel every time I get up to preach. I can tell you all about the gospel. I can tell you about what God is calling us to be and to do. I can explain what the Christian life should look like. But unless I am living that kind of life myself, I am just a fraud and a fake. Frighteningly, in the Sermon on the Mount Jesus says:
“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven. On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ Then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; go away from me, you who behave lawlessly’” (7:21-23).
Great sermons, amazing miracles, vast crowds mean nothing unless we are doing the Father’s will in our everyday life. Those moments when we are at home, or alone. When no-one else sees.
So, what do we take away from this?
- Is our life a ‘Yes’ to God, or a ‘No’.
- Are our lives producing the kind of fruit God is looking for?
- What scriptures do we really not know, because we do not obey them?
- Can we disobey ourselves in order to be able to obey God?
- Are we ‘all talk and no trousers’, or do our lives really match up to our words?
This morning, at St Mark’s we gave thanks for, celebrated, and sent off with our blessing, two people who have found the courage and the grace to say ‘Yes’ to God’s call. They have done that throughout their lives, and they are doing it again as they go to serve the church in Lille. I’m sure that their obedience is costly to them. But obedience is the path to blessing and to growth. The Kingdom of God grows through obedience.
I hope that within our two congregations, there are people who are sensing God’s call to become our new Treasurer, Bookkeeper, and second Churchwarden. May God give you the grace and courage to step out in obedience. Because obedience brings blessing, growth, and it leads to the coming of the Kingdom. Amen.










